Analysing financial statements

Tax specialists by area

Unlisted share valuation

Unlisted shares have no market to trade in, so they are valued by the method the statute prescribes. That single calculation governs the inheritance and gift tax.

Overview

Unlisted shares have no quoted price, so they are valued by the supplementary method prescribed in the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act. It takes the weighted average of the net earnings value, being the capitalised profit and loss of the past three years, and the net asset value, being assets less liabilities. The same calculation applies wherever a share value is needed: inheritance and gift, business succession, share transactions between related parties, the unwinding of a title trust, a rights issue, and the liquidation of a company.

VALUE Tax & Accounting begins by fixing the valuation base date. Where items such as provisional payments and receipts, non-recurring profit and loss, and provisions for directors' retirement benefits are left unresolved, the valuation comes out higher than it should or becomes a point of dispute with the tax office. We adjust the financial statements for valuation purposes, derive the net earnings value and the net asset value separately, and review both whether the premium applies and whether the family business deduction requirements are met, before proposing the timing of the filing and the structure of the transaction.

Key tax issues in unlisted share valuation

  1. 01

    Losses do not bring the share value down

    Even where the net earnings value is nil, eighty per cent of the net asset value sits underneath as a floor. A company holding its own premises or land sees no fall in the valuation after several loss-making years. Where the assets are mostly real estate, the net earnings value is not blended in at all and the net asset value alone is used.

  2. 02

    One year's results can swing the whole valuation

    The net earnings value weights the three preceding business years one, two and three. The most recent year carries half the weight, so a year containing a one-off gain lifts the valuation sharply. That is why the figures cannot be taken straight from the accounts.

  3. 03

    Book value gives the wrong answer

    The net asset value is not book value but the amount revalued under the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act. Land bought twenty years ago may still sit in the books at cost, but it is valued at market. The gap commonly runs to hundreds of millions of won.

  4. 04

    No premium applies to a small or medium enterprise

    Shares held by the largest shareholder and their related parties carry a premium. Shares in a small or medium enterprise are excluded by statute, so adding the premium without checking means paying tax that was never due.

  5. 05

    With a gift, the date is yours to choose

    The valuation base date is the date of death for an inheritance and the date of the gift for a gift. A dividend or a share issue shortly beforehand changes the net assets, and with them the valuation. Since the timing of a gift can be set, it is better to decide when to transfer alongside the accounting calendar.

How VALUE Tax & Accounting responds

What to bring first

Financial statements and tax adjustment statements for the past three business years, the shareholder register and the corporate registry are enough to begin. Where there is real estate we also take the property register and published price records, and where the company holds shares in a subsidiary, that company's financial statements as well.

What we strip out before any figure is produced

Provisional payments and receipts, one-off profit and loss, and provisions for directors' retirement benefits are dealt with first. Skip this and feed in the accounts as they stand, and the valuation comes out higher than it should, leaving room for a dispute with the tax office later.

What you receive alongside the valuation

We prepare the valuation schedule and the basis of the calculation for the return. You also see a table comparing how the tax changes if the timing of the gift or the structure of the transaction is altered, and we keep the adjustments and supporting material in order against later questions from the tax office.

Unlisted share valuation FAQ

Q Can unlisted shares be valued at market price? expand_more

Where there was an objective transaction between unrelated parties within the period around the valuation base date, that price is the market value. Transactions between related parties, and trades of small volume, are unlikely to be accepted as market value, so the supplementary method is used in most cases.

Q Can an appraisal be used as the reported value? expand_more

Unlike real estate, an appraised value is not accepted as the market value of unlisted shares. A valuation report may serve as supporting material, but the reported figure must rest on the method the statute prescribes.

Q Which companies are valued on the net asset value alone? expand_more

A company that has yet to begin trading, one that is dormant or closed, one in liquidation, and one whose assets are mostly real estate. In those cases the net earnings value is not blended in and the net asset value alone is used.

Q Do provisional payments affect the valuation? expand_more

Provisional payments are counted as assets and raise the net asset value, while the deemed interest is added to gross income and so affects the net earnings value as well. Where a gift or a succession is planned, clearing them in advance is the better course.

Q What if the company holds shares in a subsidiary? expand_more

Where the subsidiary is itself unlisted, its shares are valued by the same method first and the result is carried into the parent's net assets. The extra step means the records take longer to prepare.

Unlisted Share Valuation Consultation

Consultation with Choi Jun-wi, CTA is available directly via KakaoTalk, without completing a form.

Request a consultation via KakaoTalk